Not all rare earth tonnes are equal. Evaluating project economics solely on total rare earth oxide (TREO) can therefore obscure the commodities that determine commercial viability.
Heavy rare earth projects should be assessed against dysprosium and terbium (DyTb) prices, whilst light rare earth projects should be evaluated on their praseodymium-neodymium (PrNd) oxide exposure.
Benchmark released cost curves in the Q2 Benchmark Rare Earths Forecast. These are designed to compare projects within their relevant peer groups – light rare earth projects with light rare earth projects, and heavy rare earth projects with heavy rare earth projects – while also stress-testing publicly announced price floors and long-term price assumptions.
“The conclusion is that diversified rare earth supply is achievable, but the economics differ by product,” said Neha Mukherjee, Benchmark’s research manager for rare earths. “Light rare earth supply can be supported with the price floor. For heavy rare earths, however, the ex-China DyTb premium is the economic signal required to bring new capacity online. If that premium compresses through policy intervention, excess supply, or demand destruction, much of the ex-China heavy rare earth pipeline will again become unviable.”